
Common sense technique coupled with out-of-the-box thinking can help slash your living expenses.
Over the last few weeks, the missus and I have been trying to ‘optimize’ (euphemism for cutting) our living expenses. The reason for this sudden frugality exercise? Well, for once, the missus has agreed that continuously striving for greater earnings might not be such a foolproof strategy for increasing our savings, especially given the vagaries of the economic environment. Moreover, lately there has been a feeling that our expenses increase with earnings, just like the old saying - “work expands to fill the time available”. With both our companies going to great lengths to save costs, we thought the timing could not be better to start our pet project on household cost saving. Here we share with you a simple but effective approach to cost saving that worked for our family.
Step 1: Annualize expenses
Our brains don’t seem to be programmed to take small numbers seriously. This is one of the reasons why we don’t feel the guilt when we indulge in items that cost less on a per unit basis. But it could be that all these seemingly harmless small indulgences, over an entire year, could turn out to be much more expensive than some of the larger one-off expenses. The only way to cheat our brain in this (and help it visualize better) is to annualize the typical expenses that we incur in a month, under various heads, by multiplying them by 12. Obviously before doing this, you need to note down what are your expenses in a typical month, item wise, including your loan EMIs.
Some people may disagree with including EMIs. Here I think it may be a good idea to make a few assumptions: 1) EMIs going towards investment plans will create assets worth atleast the value of investment that goes into it and are hence not an expense 2) loan EMIs that do not create an asset or create a depreciating asset (e.g. a car) are an expense (so you don’t splurge on such loans) 3) in the case of home EMI, only the interest portion is an expense (this way you know that it’s better to pay it off sooner rather than later). Please note that the above are mere thumb rules.
Once you annualize the expenses on your monthly list, add to it any one-off expenses that you typically incur in a year e.g. a vacation. Now you have the annualized and itemized list of expenditure to work on. The first thing that’s going to pop out is the total annual expenses that you incur. Many people faint at this stage, because they have never bothered to actually find out how much they spend in a year! But once you have an idea of this number, you can find out how much you can potentially save in the current scenario by comparing your expenses with your annual take-home income. While doing this comparison, just keep in mind that it may be a good idea to add an additional 10% to your expense list to 1) accommodate any unexpected expenses that you may incur during the course of a year 2) account for any underestimation in your other expenses.
When we did this exercise, the first thing that shocked us was how much we spend on eating outside. The missus and myself, both being foodies, usually eat out about three times a week, so much so that it has become the primary entertainment. Separately, a weekend lunch or dinner bill for two people may not seem exorbitant; but when annualized, the amount works out to an eye-popping number!
Step 2: Fix your percentage target for cost saving
This would depend on your comfort level about the gap between your income and total expenditure. We think a 10% reduction would be an ambitious target to begin with.
Step 3: Re-arrange the annual itemized list in descending order of expenditure
Just glancing at this list, can throw some surprises in terms of things that you thought were less expensive but have turned out to be higher and vice versa.
Step 4: Mark each item as discretionary/ non-discretionary
If need be you can prepare two separate lists for discretionary and non-discretionary items. What you need to keep in mind though: neither are all non-discretionary expenses (e.g. house rent) sacrosanct nor all discretionary expenses (e.g. a movie) a waste. What’s needed is out of the box thinking that questions both kinds of expenses, and creative ways to eliminate them or come up with cheaper substitutes. Few examples: 1) switching to a smaller car, car-pooling or using metro/ MRTS to reduce transport expenses 2) repaying a loan out of your annual bonus to reduce your EMI 3) Avoiding buy now- pay later schemes
Step 5: Do a Pareto (not Burrito) analysis before deciding where to cut
Calculate the percentage share of each expense with respect to the total expenditure. What you will notice is that few items contribute a lion’s share of the expenditure. In fact it is likely that your expenses will follow the 80/20 Pareto rule i.e. 80% of total expenditure comes from 20% of the items. Even if it doesn’t exactly fit into the Pareto rule, it would be a close substitute e.g. 70/30 or 60/40. What this reinforces is the need to prioritize expenses, when pursuing your goal to cut total expenditure. If you want big savings you need to attack the big-ticket items, although they may be the toughest to reduce. Of course, it doesn’t mean that you restrict your scope only to the larger expenses. The long tail of smaller expenses do provide an opportunity for quick wins albeit not meaty ones.
Step 6: Don’t forget to implement after you have done all the planning!
Happy saving.
Over the last few weeks, the missus and I have been trying to ‘optimize’ (euphemism for cutting) our living expenses. The reason for this sudden frugality exercise? Well, for once, the missus has agreed that continuously striving for greater earnings might not be such a foolproof strategy for increasing our savings, especially given the vagaries of the economic environment. Moreover, lately there has been a feeling that our expenses increase with earnings, just like the old saying - “work expands to fill the time available”. With both our companies going to great lengths to save costs, we thought the timing could not be better to start our pet project on household cost saving. Here we share with you a simple but effective approach to cost saving that worked for our family.
Step 1: Annualize expenses
Our brains don’t seem to be programmed to take small numbers seriously. This is one of the reasons why we don’t feel the guilt when we indulge in items that cost less on a per unit basis. But it could be that all these seemingly harmless small indulgences, over an entire year, could turn out to be much more expensive than some of the larger one-off expenses. The only way to cheat our brain in this (and help it visualize better) is to annualize the typical expenses that we incur in a month, under various heads, by multiplying them by 12. Obviously before doing this, you need to note down what are your expenses in a typical month, item wise, including your loan EMIs.
Some people may disagree with including EMIs. Here I think it may be a good idea to make a few assumptions: 1) EMIs going towards investment plans will create assets worth atleast the value of investment that goes into it and are hence not an expense 2) loan EMIs that do not create an asset or create a depreciating asset (e.g. a car) are an expense (so you don’t splurge on such loans) 3) in the case of home EMI, only the interest portion is an expense (this way you know that it’s better to pay it off sooner rather than later). Please note that the above are mere thumb rules.
Once you annualize the expenses on your monthly list, add to it any one-off expenses that you typically incur in a year e.g. a vacation. Now you have the annualized and itemized list of expenditure to work on. The first thing that’s going to pop out is the total annual expenses that you incur. Many people faint at this stage, because they have never bothered to actually find out how much they spend in a year! But once you have an idea of this number, you can find out how much you can potentially save in the current scenario by comparing your expenses with your annual take-home income. While doing this comparison, just keep in mind that it may be a good idea to add an additional 10% to your expense list to 1) accommodate any unexpected expenses that you may incur during the course of a year 2) account for any underestimation in your other expenses.
When we did this exercise, the first thing that shocked us was how much we spend on eating outside. The missus and myself, both being foodies, usually eat out about three times a week, so much so that it has become the primary entertainment. Separately, a weekend lunch or dinner bill for two people may not seem exorbitant; but when annualized, the amount works out to an eye-popping number!
Step 2: Fix your percentage target for cost saving
This would depend on your comfort level about the gap between your income and total expenditure. We think a 10% reduction would be an ambitious target to begin with.
Step 3: Re-arrange the annual itemized list in descending order of expenditure
Just glancing at this list, can throw some surprises in terms of things that you thought were less expensive but have turned out to be higher and vice versa.
Step 4: Mark each item as discretionary/ non-discretionary
If need be you can prepare two separate lists for discretionary and non-discretionary items. What you need to keep in mind though: neither are all non-discretionary expenses (e.g. house rent) sacrosanct nor all discretionary expenses (e.g. a movie) a waste. What’s needed is out of the box thinking that questions both kinds of expenses, and creative ways to eliminate them or come up with cheaper substitutes. Few examples: 1) switching to a smaller car, car-pooling or using metro/ MRTS to reduce transport expenses 2) repaying a loan out of your annual bonus to reduce your EMI 3) Avoiding buy now- pay later schemes
Step 5: Do a Pareto (not Burrito) analysis before deciding where to cut
Calculate the percentage share of each expense with respect to the total expenditure. What you will notice is that few items contribute a lion’s share of the expenditure. In fact it is likely that your expenses will follow the 80/20 Pareto rule i.e. 80% of total expenditure comes from 20% of the items. Even if it doesn’t exactly fit into the Pareto rule, it would be a close substitute e.g. 70/30 or 60/40. What this reinforces is the need to prioritize expenses, when pursuing your goal to cut total expenditure. If you want big savings you need to attack the big-ticket items, although they may be the toughest to reduce. Of course, it doesn’t mean that you restrict your scope only to the larger expenses. The long tail of smaller expenses do provide an opportunity for quick wins albeit not meaty ones.
Step 6: Don’t forget to implement after you have done all the planning!
Happy saving.

8 comments:
talking about substitutes, there are some like visiting a garden instead of multiplex which is infact better as well as cheaper
-Milind
Hi Shyam,
Good article. As you said, common sense.
To go a little deeper, you can also itemize the expenses against the day of week. This will be useful to cut down on combinational expenses.
For example, you go to a multiplex and popcorn/gelato/coke comes up as a side expense. Another possibility is the impulsive shopping.
It's possible to cut down once we are conscious of this. We can decide to stick to the movie and go to a restaurant for food. This will definitely be better than the junk food we have at the multiplex.
Finally, an excellent tool which can help in this and much more - GnuCash
Regards,
Anand
ps:
I am already tracking all the expenses in an Excel sheet. Only missing item is the Pareto. Thanks for that - will add to my template.
hi shyam nice article........
it really helps us to understand that where we have to restrict ourself in matter of over spending.....
moral of articles is start saving now KYA PATAA KAL HOO NAA HOO.....
another moral is "its better to control now else...........
thanks for wonderful article
Lucid!
Always a pleasure to read your articles, Shyam.
Liked the point you made on the EMIs- which is a silent killer in my case
srikant
Milind - obvious alternative but very few seem to prefer it . maybe that's bcoz even the few public spaces that remain in cities are not worth a visit thanks to:
poor maintenance, their use as haven for beggars, overcrowding etc.
Anand - agree with the multiplex thing. but i think it's really the herd phenomenon. looking at all the others walking in with their popcorn and coke after 'intermission'...hard to get over the temptation! I dont think people can resist this unless theatres get rid of intermissions or movies become shorter - both utopian goals! thanks for the GNUcash suggestion...will check it out.
Srikant - glad you like 'em
Hi Shyam,
Good article. However, my question is related to what you wrote once about Nifty BEES in The Hindu.
Can we go intraday in NiftyBees?
My id is raghavansrivathsan@gmail.com
Hi Shyam,
An informative article ;
I had a suggestion ;
Usually we have some planned expenses over a period of time say some expense to occur after 10 months of time then planning expenses yearly helps accumulating money in better way ;
we can start putting money for 10 months in a RD and we might have to effectively splurge less on our expenses...
Step 1 to 6 are well taken. Especially 6!
I would also point to getting and using a good spreadsheet or tracker to get it all started! You need to start measuring things first before you arrive at Step 2-3.
Post a Comment